How Medieval People Invented Horror Movies (And They Were Way More Disturbing Than Netflix)
By History's Hot Takes Chuckscooldesigns
Think modern horror is scary? Try living in medieval Europe, where every shadow could be a demon, your neighbor might be a witch, and the doctor treating your illness looked like a literal bird-monster from hell. Modern horror directors spend millions creating terrifying imagery that medieval people genuinely believed was walking around their villages every single day.Netflix's scariest series can't compete with the psychological terror of genuinely believing that werewolves were real, demons were constantly trying to steal your soul, and the boundary between the living and dead completely disappeared every October 31st. Medieval people didn't watch horror—they lived it. Their entire worldview was essentially a 24/7 horror movie with no credits rolling to signal safety.Today we're exploring how medieval people invented every horror trope we know, believed in monsters that make modern villains look tame, and turned their genuine supernatural terror into traditions we now celebrate with cute decorations and candy. Because it turns out, when you dig into the history, our "scary" Halloween is basically medieval nightmare fuel that's been domesticated into family-friendly fun.
Watch the Full Story Before we dive into medieval nightmares, check out our full video breakdown of how medieval people lived in constant supernatural terror.
Werewolves: The Original Body HorrorLet's start with werewolves, because medieval Europe was obsessed with the idea that your friendly neighbor could transform into a bloodthirsty wolf-monster. This wasn't folklore they enjoyed around campfires—this was genuine, widespread terror that resulted in trials, executions, and entire communities living in fear.
Medieval Werewolf Beliefs Were Horrifying
Hollywood werewolves are tragic figures—cursed souls struggling with their dual nature, often portrayed sympathetically. Medieval werewolves were straight-up cannibalistic murderers who happened to grow fur. There was no inner conflict, no romantic subplot, no cure through the power of love. Just people who transformed into wolves and ate children.The stories medieval people told about werewolves make modern horror look like Disney movies. Werewolves would dig up fresh graves to eat corpses. They would attack children in their beds. They would stalk travelers on dark roads. And the transformation wasn't some dramatic Hollywood effect—it was described as a horrifying, painful process that left the person's humanity completely gone.The Beast of Gévaudan, a wolf-like creature that terrorized southern France in the 1760s (technically post-medieval, but the beliefs were the same), allegedly killed over 100 people. Entire communities organized armed hunts because they genuinely believed a werewolf was among them. Imagine that level of terror—not knowing which of your neighbors might transform and murder you.
Courts Actually Tried People for Lycanthropy
Here's where it gets even darker: European courts held actual legal trials for werewolf accusations. People were tried, convicted, and executed for being werewolves. Not metaphorical werewolves—literal werewolves.In 1589, Peter Stumpp in Germany was tried for being a werewolf. The accusations included killing and eating fourteen children, two pregnant women, and various livestock. Under torture (because of course torture was involved), he confessed to making a pact with the devil who gave him a magical belt that transformed him into a wolf.He was convicted. And his execution was medieval-level brutal: broken on the wheel, beheaded, and then burned. They also executed his daughter and mistress for good measure. All because people genuinely believed he turned into a wolf and ate people.This wasn't some isolated incident. Werewolf trials happened across Europe for centuries. The last official werewolf execution was in the 18th century. People were dying because their communities believed in monsters that modern audiences watch for entertainment.
The Legal Framework for Monster Hunting
Medieval and early modern Europe had actual legal procedures for dealing with supernatural threats. Werewolves, like witches, fell under both religious and secular law. There were official methods for identifying werewolves (examining bodies for "devil's marks," looking for hair on the palms, etc.) and prescribed punishments.Imagine explaining to your insurance company that your house was damaged in a werewolf attack and having them actually investigate the claim. That's essentially what medieval legal systems did. The supernatural wasn't fantasy—it was covered under law.
Demons Everywhere: Medieval Paranormal Activity
If werewolves were medieval Europe's stalking predators, demons were their invasive species—constantly present, impossible to eliminate, and blamed for literally everything that went wrong.
The Corporate Structure of Hell
Medieval people didn't just believe demons existed—they had a complete organizational chart for them. Demonology was a serious academic discipline. Scholars wrote detailed texts categorizing demons by their powers, hierarchies, and specializations.There were demons for lust, demons for pride, demons for causing nightmares, demons for spoiling food, demons for making you impotent, demons for hiding your keys. Every minor inconvenience could be demonic interference. Bad harvest? Demons. Milk went sour? Demons. Can't sleep? Demons. Stubbed your toe? Probably demons.The bestselling book Malleus Maleficarum (1487) was essentially a demon-hunting manual that described in detail how demons operated, how to identify demonic possession, and how to combat supernatural threats. It was incredibly popular—went through multiple printings, was used by both Catholic and Protestant authorities, and helped fuel centuries of witch hunts.This book made medieval people paranoid about supernatural threats in their daily lives. It's like if someone published a serious academic paper about how ghosts are definitely trying to steal your Netflix password, and everyone believed it and started performing exorcisms on their TVs.
Daily Life With Demons
Medieval people integrated demonic threats into their daily routines. You would make the sign of the cross before eating to prevent demons from poisoning your food. You would say prayers before bed to keep demons from causing nightmares. You would bless your livestock to protect them from demonic interference.Churches sold holy water, blessed medals, protective prayers, and other anti-demon merchandise. The medieval version of a home security system was religious symbols strategically placed around your house.And if something went wrong despite your precautions? Well, clearly you hadn't been pious enough, or the demons were particularly powerful, or God was testing you. The system was unfalsifiable—there was always an explanation for why demons succeeded despite your protections.Living in medieval Europe meant living in constant low-level anxiety about supernatural threats. Modern horror movies let you experience that feeling for 90 minutes and then return to safety. Medieval people never got to leave the theater.
Witch Trials: Mass Hysteria on an Industrial Scale
Werewolves and demons were scary, but witch hunts were where medieval supernatural terror turned into actual mass murder.
The Numbers Are StaggeringBetween roughly 1450 and 1750 (extending beyond the medieval period proper, but rooted in medieval beliefs), approximately 40,000-60,000 people were executed for witchcraft in Europe and colonial America. Some estimates go higher. That's more deaths than most horror movie franchises combined.These weren't isolated incidents. They were systematic, community-wide panics that could last for years. Salem is the most famous example in American history, but European witch hunts were far more extensive and brutal.
The "Evidence" Was Insane
Medieval and early modern witch hunters used "evidence" that would make modern conspiracy theorists look rational. Let's look at how you could be identified as a witch:
If you floated in water, you were a witch (because pure water rejected evil).
If you sank, you were innocent (but you might drown in the process, so... condolences).
If you had a birthmark, mole, or unusual skin feature, that was a "devil's mark" proving demonic connection.
If you owned a cat, especially a black cat, that was your "familiar" (demon companion).
If you were an older woman who lived alone, that was suspicious.
If your neighbors' crops failed after you argued with them, you had clearly cursed them.
If you confessed under torture, that proved you were a witch.
If you refused to confess under torture, that proved demons were strengthening you, so you were definitely a witch.The system was designed so that once you were accused, you were essentially guilty. There was no good outcome.
How Witch Hunts Spread
One accusation could trigger a cascade. Accused witches were tortured until they named accomplices. Those people were arrested and tortured until they named more people. Each confession expanded the conspiracy, and soon entire communities were gripped by witch-hunting fever.It's like a viral social media panic, except instead of getting cancelled online, you were burned at the stake.The psychological terror of living during a witch hunt must have been overwhelming. Anyone could be accused. Your neighbor, your family member, yourself. One bad harvest, one argument, one strange dream someone had about you, and you could be arrested, tortured, and executed.Modern horror movies give us villains we can identify and (theoretically) defeat. Witch hunts turned everyone into potential monsters and made trust impossible.
Plague Doctors: When Medical Professionals Looked Like Death Itself
Speaking of nightmare fuel, let's talk about plague doctors—the medical professionals who dressed like demons and probably caused as much psychological trauma as they prevented physical disease.
The Most Terrifying Costume in HistoryThe plague doctor outfit is iconic: long black coat, wide-brimmed hat, leather gloves, and that infamous bird-like mask with glass eye-pieces and a long beak.The mask was stuffed with aromatics—herbs, flowers, perfumes—because medieval medicine believed disease spread through "bad air" (miasma). The beak made plague doctors look like demonic bird-creatures, and that was before they showed up at your door to tell you that you had the plague.Imagine you're sick, feverish, possibly delirious. There's a knock at your door. You open it, and standing there is a six-foot-tall bird-monster in black robes carrying a stick. That's not medical care—that's a literal nightmare made flesh.Modern horror costume designers spend fortunes creating scary imagery that doesn't approach the authentic terror of genuine plague doctor gear.The Psychological Impact Was IntentionalThe plague doctor costume was meant to be intimidating. It signaled that plague was present, death was near, and supernatural forces might be at work. The outfit separated plague doctors from normal humans—they became something other, something that walked between the living and the dead.For communities experiencing plague outbreaks, seeing a plague doctor was confirmation that the worst was happening. The costume was a walking omen of death.And the treatment? Plague doctors would lance the buboes (swollen lymph nodes), perform bloodletting, and administer various ineffective remedies. Many patients died despite—or sometimes because of—the treatment.So plague doctors were terrifying nightmare figures who showed up when you were dying and then often hastened your death through medieval medical practices. They're basically medical Grim Reapers with worse fashion sense.
Plague Doctors in Modern Horror
Modern horror costume industries make millions selling plague doctor masks and costumes. They're instantly recognizable as creepy. But we've domesticated them—turned them into Halloween decorations and cosplay.Medieval people seeing plague doctors didn't think "cool costume." They thought "oh god, the plague is here, everyone I know might die."That's the difference between modern horror (entertainment) and medieval horror (reality).
Ancient Halloween: When the Dead Actually Visited
Modern Halloween involves costumes, candy, and maybe watching scary movies. Ancient Samhain (the Celtic festival that became Halloween) was about genuine belief that the boundary between the living and dead dissolved completely.
The Original Halloween Was Terrifying
Ancient Celtic people believed that on Samhain (October 31st), the veil between the world of the living and the world of the dead became so thin that spirits, fairies, and demons could cross over freely. This wasn't symbolic—they genuinely believed their villages would be full of supernatural entities for one night.People would light massive bonfires to ward off evil spirits. They would wear frightening masks and costumes to confuse demons so they wouldn't be recognized as humans. They would leave food outside their doors to appease potentially dangerous spirits.The jack-o'-lantern originated as a protective talisman. The original versions were carved from turnips (not pumpkins—those came later in America) and were meant to be genuinely frightening. They were supposed to scare away malevolent spirits, not decorate your porch.
Divination and Death Predictions
Samhain was also prime time for divination—trying to predict the future, especially deaths in the coming year. There were rituals for determining who would die, who would marry, and what the next year would bring.Imagine celebrating a holiday where part of the tradition is figuring out which of your family members will die in the next twelve months. That's not a fun party game—that's psychological horror.Ancient people took these predictions seriously. If a divination ritual suggested you would die that year, you genuinely believed it. The anxiety and dread would follow you for months.
How We Domesticated Fear
Modern Halloween took all these genuine terrors and turned them into family entertainment. We kept the superficial elements—costumes, jack-o'-lanterns, supernatural themes—but removed the actual belief and fear.We turned werewolves into costume options. We turned demons into decorations. We turned the night when the dead walked the earth into an excuse to eat candy.It's the ultimate example of cultural sanitization. We took the most terrifying night of the year and made it cute.But if you dig into the history, every Halloween tradition is rooted in genuine supernatural terror. The trick-or-treating is paying off potentially dangerous spirits. The costumes are protection against demons. The jack-o'-lanterns are weapons against evil.We're celebrating medieval nightmare fuel while eating fun-size Snickers bars.
Why Medieval Horror Was More Disturbing Than Modern Horror
Modern horror movies can be incredibly effective. They use sound design, visual effects, jump scares, and psychological manipulation to create fear. But they have one fundamental limitation: you know they're not real.Medieval horror didn't have that limitation.
Genuine Belief Changes Everything
When you watch a horror movie, part of your brain knows you're safe. The monster isn't real. You can leave the theater. You can turn off the TV.Medieval people couldn't turn off their beliefs. Werewolves were real. Demons were real. Witches were real. The supernatural threats weren't entertainment—they were daily reality.That changes the psychological impact completely. Modern horror gives you adrenaline spikes in a controlled environment. Medieval horror gave you chronic, inescapable anxiety about supernatural threats that could strike at any time.
No Escape, No Solution
Modern horror movies usually offer some kind of resolution. The monster can be defeated, the ghost can be appeased, the curse can be broken. There's a solution, even if it's difficult.Medieval supernatural threats had no reliable solutions. You could pray, use holy symbols, avoid suspicious behaviors, but ultimately, if demons wanted to torment you or witches wanted to curse you, there wasn't much you could do.The randomness and inevitability of supernatural threats made them more terrifying than any movie monster. At least movie monsters have consistent rules and weaknesses. Medieval demons could do whatever they wanted.
The Authority Figures Believed It Too
In modern horror, often the protagonist has to convince others that the threat is real. There's usually a skeptical authority figure who doesn't believe in ghosts/monsters/curses.In medieval Europe, the authority figures were the ones most convinced of supernatural threats. The Church taught that demons were real. Courts tried werewolves and witches. Medical professionals believed in humoral imbalances and demonic possession.There was no one to turn to who would say "this is irrational, these beliefs aren't real." Everyone—from peasants to kings—shared the same supernatural worldview.That meant there was no reality check, no voice of reason, no way to step back and question whether these fears were justified.
The Legacy: Modern Horror Is Medieval Horror Lite
Every modern horror trope has medieval roots:
Werewolves? Medieval courts executed people for it.
Demonic possession? Medieval demonology gave us the detailed mythology.
Witch hunts? Literally from medieval witch trials.
Haunted houses? Based on medieval beliefs about spirits in places of death.
Cursed objects? Medieval superstitions about demonic contamination.
Zombies? Based partially on medieval beliefs about corpses rising from graves.Modern horror directors aren't inventing these concepts. They're borrowing from a medieval worldview that genuinely believed all of this was real.The difference is that we get to enjoy the fear as entertainment, with the safety net of knowing it's fiction. Medieval people had no safety net.
Why We Should Remember the Real Terror
These stories are entertaining to us now, but they represent genuine suffering. Thousands of people died in witch hunts because of supernatural beliefs. Communities lived in constant anxiety about demonic threats. People experienced psychological trauma from living in a worldview where monsters were real.Understanding medieval horror isn't just about appreciating where modern horror comes from. It's about recognizing how beliefs—even irrational ones—can cause real harm when they're widely accepted and institutionalized.It's also a reminder that humans are capable of believing almost anything if the cultural context supports it. Medieval people weren't stupid or primitive. They were using the best information and frameworks available to them to explain a terrifying world.We might look back and think "how could they believe in werewolves?" But future generations might look at our beliefs and think the same thing.The real horror isn't the monsters. It's what humans do to each other when they believe monsters are real.
Want More Historical Horror?
If you enjoyed learning about how medieval people invented horror, we've got plenty more where this came from:Subscribe to History's Hot Takes on YouTube for weekly videos covering:
New videos every week. Because history is too weird to be boring.
Final ThoughtsModern horror is impressive. Directors use sophisticated techniques to scare us in controlled environments. But medieval horror was operating on a different level entirely—because it wasn't horror, it was reality.Every creepy Halloween decoration, every horror movie monster, every supernatural threat we enjoy as entertainment has roots in beliefs that caused genuine terror and real suffering.Next time you watch a horror movie, remember: medieval people were living in that movie 24/7, with no credits rolling, no lights coming on, and no reassurance that the monsters weren't real.They invented horror because they lived in it.And honestly? That's more disturbing than anything Netflix could produce.About History's Hot Takes: We tell you the history they left out of textbooks—the weird, the terrifying, the uncomfortable truths that make the past more interesting than any fiction. Subscribe for weekly videos that mix sarcasm with facts you'll actually remember.Follow us: